황금률(남에게 대접받고자 하는대로 남을 대접하라)은 NGO 등으로 대변되는 가난한 국가에 대한 일종의 간섭주의이다.
The Golden Rule (do to others what you want them to do to you) is an invitation to interventionism, utopianism, and meddling into other people's affairs, particularly poor nations, as represented by the the NGO clowns at TED conferences trying to "save the world", and causing more harm with unseen side effects. Remember that Mao, Stalin, Lenin, and were following the positive Golden rule. At the personal level, I may feel good trying to nudge a vegetarian to eat raw kebbeh (Lebanese steak tartare) because I like it myself.
The Silver rule (do NOT do to others what you don't want them to do to you) leads to a systematic way to live "doing no harm" and gives rise to a liberating type of ethics: your obligation is to pursue your personal interests provided you do not hurt others probabilistically unless you are yourself exposed, & not transfer risks to others (skin-in-the-game at all times). But, and here is the key, should there be a spillover, it will necessarily be positive. It is therefore convex.(Typical via negativa rules are convex). It separates the "self-interest" in Adam Smith from the "selfish" version. And if you want to help society, just try to benefit WHILE at least harming no one.
This distinction puts a lot of clarity behind the idea of free markets and morality. You should never have to prove that what you do is GOOD for society (hard to express in words and rationalistic framework), but you can certainly show you are NOT hurting others more than yourself via skin-in-the-game.
'멘토 FollowTheMentor > 나심 니콜라스 탈레브' 카테고리의 다른 글
|<안티프래질> 2장. 과잉보상과 과잉반응 (0)||2017.05.31|
|<안티프래질> 1장. 다모클레스와 히드라 (0)||2017.05.31|
|황금률은 일종의 간섭주의이다. (0)||2014.06.28|
|The Triad - Fragile, Robust, Anti-fragile by NNT (0)||2013.09.26|
|빅데이터는 무엇이 옳은가가 아니라 무엇이 그른가를 말해준다 Big data can tell us what’s wrong, not what’s right. (0)||2013.02.16|
|대학학위는 단지 그저 바이너리(binary)로 보아야 하는 것이다 (0)||2013.01.24|